Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
lawyers weekly logo
Borrower

Online mortgage platforms ‘fraught with danger’

6 minute read
The Adviser

A Melbourne-based mortgage consultant says he believes the emerging popularity of price-driven online mortgage platforms could be “fraught with danger” and problematic for consumers.

Echoing concerns voiced by the FBAA last year over online mortgage providers, Vincent Moore of Stratton Finance told the Elite Broker podcast that broker advice would remain necessary for consumers as online mortgage platforms would not be able to accurately address the individual issues of different clients.

“I think if every client was a really strong applicant, could pick any lender they wanted to go to, had consistent income, had good savings [and] had a good deposit, then sure – they would work for those models,” he explained.

“[But] there are a lot of clients who have no idea what a bank would say yes [to] and what a bank would say no to.”

 
 

Mr Moore noted that income write-offs, self-employment and property sizes were among the common issues for banks restricting their lending to consumers.

He added that while these online platforms could indeed work for “vanilla-type clients who are really strong”, clients who use brokers are generally consumers in need of assistance, as they had been “knocked back from one bank already and need to be guided”.

“They need to be [told], ‘Hey look, this lender’s going to say no. But at the same time, this lender’s going to say yes for these reasons',” he said.

“There [are] so many issues that… those online systems are not going to be able to address accurately and there [are] too many little things that I don't think a system can catch without you talking to someone,” he concluded. 

Listen to Vincent’s episode of the Elite Broker podcast from Monday, 13 February.

[Related: Lender explains decision to ‘steer away’ from brokers]

default

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

You need to be a member to post comments. Become a member for free today!

Comments (5)

  • The problem is, I think you are being very naive in this article, the use of AI of today means that the algorithms used within the software make it extremely easy for an automated "Robo-advice" machine, be it mortgage broking or playing chess, to be continuously updated with market information and be able to answer all client problems.
    Forget the "oh but they will always need .a human contact" incorrect, the millennials of today reach for the mobile phone for everything.
    The author or broker making the statement is, IMHO, incorrect and the time has come to stop burying your head in the sand and start to look at how, you should maybe, start to change your business model to work with the Fintech changes that in 2-3 years time will change the industry.
    0
    • AI is a long way off from reading and interpreting Self Employed Financial Reports and Tax Returns not to mention interpreting lender policy or knowing what lenders will create exceptions for certain policies. AI has a place, for vanilla type deals, not for more complex scenarios, at least not now or in the near future.
      1
      • Actually not correct. AI technology & algorithms are advancing at an incredible rate and already being tested by many Financial Organisations. It is a matter of time before customers can have a conversation with an avatar that is better at reading emotions and responding accordingly than anyone who carries a human bias, and computer analysis will be far quicker and more accurate that anything done by the human brain.
        There will always be a place for human connection, especially with a decision as big as a mortgage, however we need to embrace these technologies rather than pretend they're going away.
        0
        • Lots of talk for many years on tech doing away with brokers.

          Yet every time new lending tech comes out, I see greater need for the role of a broker, as the tech never quite delivers and/or often makes things more complicated for the customer.

          Eventually they will get the tech right, but brokers will be around for many years still.

          As for the emotion reading avatar broker you speak of, let's just say I'll believe it when I see it.

          I'm all for technical advances, I can't believe how backwards most lenders are. However before we can revolutionize lending with tech, first we need to get lenders out of the 1980's & 90's (seriously these big multi billion dollar companies are decades behind the times with some of their systems and processes).

          How about CBA's laughable revolutionary apply-online document upload system? It now takes about 30 minutes to do what I used to do in a 30 second email.
          0
    • Not naive just a little circumspect. I think most of these fintech players (if not all) have to maintain a "profile" and this means that they tend to overstate (just a little) their current abilities as well as their future abilities, bit like an aggregator (hahaha oh I just crack me up). Yep the millennials do reach for their phone but if it can't give them what they want they will then make the effort to speak with someone. The other thing I have noticed with millennials is that they value information, they don't approach it, initially, with the I know everything attitude. The other issue facing the fintechs in the mortgage market they actually don't have the funding, not like car, personal, small business and peer to peer. At the end of the day they are just like us and have to go to the lender "cap in hand" and the lender has the final say. With online fraud having a greater impact the lenders are, justifiably, a little worried in this space. While I agree the head in the sand approach, at any stage of your business, is always two steps back I don't think it will have any "significant impact" within the next 5 years. If you look at your book, then drill down to the millennials, then how many did something without a family guarantee or online it would be very small and sure it only has one way to go but it's from a very low base. Anyone remember hero broker, or broker hero (can't remember the name) but he was a millennial himself and it appeared that he really didn't understand the industry but "busted in" with lots of fanfare only to vanish pretty quickly. Sure he was going to do different things but nothing has happened and I think, certainly at this stage, this is the reality for online in the short term. I just read where HashChing took in 70M in enquiries in a day or maybe two days, but only 7 million ended up in applications and no doubt a smaller number again actually settled and therefore earned any income. Take away the costs to manage this and it would be interesting to see the profit, if any, from all that activity.

      Now don't even started me on AI, I have seen it in action with various apps. It's great...but only for repetitive tasks. And while it "learns" it's really more of a if this happens that many times then you should do this, if, if, else. AI will have it's best start in repetitive tasks in a CONTROLLED environment. All AI development is done with full control which is not offered with finance, think about all the people involved. It is getting there but again for a complex transaction like a mortgage where there are multiple people, organisations, government departments etc involved it's just not going to happen...in the next 2-3 years.

      Fintechs will/should/could have a place in our industry but it is still a little way away. I know it sounds "sexy" but like an internet date it won't look anything like it's photo! :-)
      1
Attach images by dragging & dropping or by selecting them.
The maximum file size for uploads is MB. Only files are allowed.
 
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
The maximum number of 3 allowed files to upload has been reached. If you want to upload more files you have to delete one of the existing uploaded files first.
Posting as
magazine
Read the latest issue of The Adviser magazine!
The Adviser is the number one magazine for Australia's finance and mortgage brokers. The publications delivers news, analysis, business intelligence, sales and marketing strategies, research and key target reports to an audience of professional mortgage and finance brokers
Read more
You have3 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content, or become a PREMIUM MEMBER to enjoy a wide range of benefits
You have 3 free articles left this month.
Register for a free account to access unlimited free content, or become a PREMIUM MEMBER to enjoy a wide range of benefits